Lahore Food Guide / Make ahead

Shami Kabab Recipe: The Ratio Most Recipes Agree On

By Lahori Food Team Β· 19 November 2026

We compared seven shami kabab recipes to find the meat-to-chana-dal ratio that works, why kababs break, and how to freeze a batch.

Shami kabab recipe: the ratio that works

By Lahori Food Team Β· Updated 20 November 2026

Every family has its own shami, and every recipe online seems to disagree. We compared seven of them to find the meat-to-dal ratio most cooks land on, why shami kababs break in the pan, and how to freeze a batch so Ramzan is easier.

Quick answer: use about 4–5 parts meat to 1 part dry chana dal by weight, for example 900 g beef to 200 g dal. Boil them together with whole spices until the meat falls apart, then keep cooking until the mix is completely dry. Grind, add fresh herbs, shape and shallow-fry on medium heat. A dry mix is what stops shami from breaking.

How we wrote this: we compared seven published recipes (Pakistani food blogs and one popular YouTube recipe) and food-safety guidance from the US Department of Agriculture. We haven't tested this recipe in our own kitchen yet; we'll update this page when we do.

Seven recipes compared

Recipe Meat Chana dal Meat to dal Egg
Tea for Turmeric 680 g beef mince about 200 g about 3.4 : 1 No
Flour & Spice 900 g beef or mutton 200 g 4.5 : 1 No
But First, Chai 1 kg beef 250 g 4 : 1 Optional
Nine Foods 500 g beef about 100 g 5 : 1 As a coating
Marium Hosein 900 g beef about 150 g 6 : 1 –
Meaningful Masala 1 kg beef about 50 g 20 : 1 Yes
YouTube freezer recipe (chicken) 1 kg chicken 500 g 2 : 1 No (uses a binder)

Most beef recipes sit between 4 : 1 and 5 : 1. More dal gives a softer, more crumbly kabab that holds together well in the freezer; less dal gives a meatier one that needs a drier mix (or an egg) to hold.

Why it works. Chana dal cooks down into a starchy paste that binds the shredded meat, so you don't need flour. Boiling whole spices with the meat flavours it all the way through. Cooking off every last bit of water is the step most people rush, and a wet mix is the main reason shami falls apart in the pan.

Lahori beef shami kabab

Makes about 20Soak 4 hoursCook about 2 hours

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount What to do with it
1. Into the pot
Boneless beef 900 g Cut into cubes. Keep a little fat on, it keeps the kababs soft.
Chana dal (split Bengal gram) 200 g Wash, soak for 4 hours, then drain.
Onion 1 medium Roughly chop.
Garlic 8 cloves Peel, leave whole.
Ginger 2-inch piece Peel and slice.
Whole spices 1 tbsp coriander seeds, 1 tsp cumin, 1Β½ tsp black peppercorns, 6 cloves, 1 black cardamom, 1 small cinnamon stick Add whole. You'll pick out the cinnamon and cardamom later.
Dried red chillies 6–8 (or 1Β½ tsp flakes) Add whole.
Salt 2 tsp Add now, adjust at the end.
Water 3–4 cups Just enough to cover.
2. Mix in after grinding
Mint and coriander A handful each Chop finely.
Green chillies 3–4 Chop finely.
Onion 1 small Chop very finely, then squeeze out the water. Wet onion breaks kababs.
Egg (optional) 1 Beat and mix in, or keep for coating.
3. To fry
Oil About Β½ cup For shallow frying on medium heat.

Method

  1. 1

    Boil 1–1Β½ hours

    Put the beef, drained dal, onion, garlic, ginger, whole spices, red chillies and salt in a heavy pot.

    Add water to just cover.

    Bring to a boil, then cover and simmer until the beef shreds easily and the dal is soft.

  2. 2

    Dry it out 15–20 minutes

    Uncover and turn up the heat.

    Keep stirring until every bit of water has gone and the mix looks dry and starts to stick.

    Don't skip this. A wet mix is the main reason shami breaks.

  3. 3

    Grind 5 minutes

    Let it cool a little.

    Pick out the cinnamon stick and black cardamom.

    Grind or pound until smooth, with a little texture left.

  4. 4

    Mix 5 minutes

    Stir in the mint, coriander, green chillies and squeezed onion.

    Add the egg if you're using it.

    Taste and add salt.

  5. 5

    Shape 15 minutes

    Wet your hands.

    Make about 20 flat, round patties of around 55 g each.

    Freezing? Stop here and see "How to freeze" below.

  6. 6

    Fry 2–3 minutes a side

    Heat the oil on medium.

    Shallow-fry until deep brown on both sides.

    For a lacy coat, dip each kabab in beaten egg just before frying.

Chicken shami

Use 900 g boneless chicken instead of beef (thigh stays juicier than breast) and simmer for 30–40 minutes instead. Chicken has less fat and dries out more easily, which is why freezer recipes often use more dal, up to 1 part dal to 2 parts chicken.

Why shami kababs break

  • The mix is wet. The most common cause. Cook it until it's completely dry before grinding, and squeeze the water out of raw onion before mixing it in.
  • The oil isn't hot enough, or you flip too early. Let the first side brown and set before turning.
  • Too little dal or binder. With very little dal, add an egg to the mix.
  • Frying straight from the freezer on a cold pan. Heat the oil first and keep the heat at medium.

How to freeze shami kababs

  1. 1

    Freeze flat 2–3 hours

    Lay the shaped kababs on a tray lined with butter paper, not touching.

    Freeze until firm.

    Some cooks fry them briefly first for colour.

  2. 2

    Bag and label

    Move them into a sealed freezer bag and press the air out.

    Write the date on it.

    For the best taste, use them within 2–3 months, the USDA advises for cooked meat; they stay safe longer but lose quality.

  3. 3

    Fry from frozen

    No need to thaw.

    Fry on medium heat.

    Expect them to take about one and a half times as long as fresh, according to the USDA.

Short on time before Ramzan? Frozen shami kababs exist, ours included: Lahore Eatery chicken shami kebabs.

Questions people ask

Which dal is used in shami kabab?

Chana dal, also called split Bengal gram or yellow split peas. Soak it for 1–6 hours first; the longer it soaks, the faster it cooks.

Can I make shami kabab without egg?

Yes. Most of the recipes we compared skip the egg. A completely dry mix with enough dal holds together on its own.

Why are my shami kababs hard?

Usually too little fat in the meat, or the mix was cooked so long it turned crumbly before grinding. Use meat with some fat, and stop drying once no water is left.

How long can I freeze shami kababs?

For the best taste, 2–3 months, following the USDA's guidance for cooked meat. Keep them sealed so they don't dry out.

Sources (checked 16 November 2026): Tea for Turmeric Β· Flour & Spice Β· But First, Chai Β· Nine Foods Β· Meaningful Masala Β· YouTube chicken shami Β· USDA: Freezing and Food Safety. Photo: Lahore Eatery.

More from the Lahore Food Guide